Friday, April 10, 2009

marble cake

ok..this was something really spontaneous. I had attempted butter cakes sometime ago in between my "mini hitiaus" but was just too lazy to take pics and post about them. Besides, they were nothing fantastic. Plus, I was upset that i couldn't even handle butter cakes.

speaking of how did I arrive at wanting to make butter cakes, Ian's grandma was asking me at the party if I made butter cakes and if i did how do I make it etc etc..And it struck to me that "hey! you haven't even attempted a simple butter cake!". She asked of a trusted recipe, if i had one, and so of course, I went home and made a search for it. I remember reading from Rei's blog about some marble cake she made to be given away as gifts for her son's first month celebration. Which received RAVE reviews and that she cited her recipe back to aunty yochana's butter cake. So, that's how it all started.

The recipe couldn't look any simpler BUT when I attempted, it failed. it was still edible nonetheless, but i seemed to have encountered all the problems other readers left on the comments section for aunty yochana's post! how devasting right? =( k, that aside, it left me worried, restless, and 不甘心. Everything felt weird right from the start, perhaps I underestimated the recipe and overestimated my abilities. Aunty yochana's recipe uses the egg separation method which is supposed to work wonderfully! (just like a chiffon right, so i thought it should be a breeze since i succeeded at chiffons before, but no, i did not.)

1. everything went well with creaming butter and sugar and adding in eggs. trouble started when i added in the flour. it literally became a dough.

2. Recipe stated to whip whites to soft peaks. I underwhiped and it totally had no effect on lightening the "dough" mixture.

3.the batter ended up like a pancake/waffle batter. Zzz.

4.that spelled D-I-S-A-S-T-E-R

5. cake rose, and CRACKED.

6. i had the "bubbles" problem all over the cake surface.

The second attempt went on much much better, i whipped the egg whites longer, and the butter/egg mixture was much workable, and this time, it resembled a cake batter. however, i left the cake to cool in the pan (as I was rushing for school and wasn't sure if i should cool it or remove it). When I was back from school. the cake shrank from the sides and in height. though i thought the cake was gonna be some dense pound cake, it did not! haha..and boy was I glad my mum polished off by bringing it to her friends for some gathering hehe!

so after those 2 attempts, I couldn't consider myself having succeeded with this supposedly darn good recipe.

After a chat over msn with Ian's mummy and passing her the links to the recipe, i convinced myself that yes, now's the time to try it again. So this time, i did a marble cake. I've always loved marble cakes and always wanted to bake them. I'm aware of how simple it is actually to obtain those lovely marbles but have just not gotten around to making it. So, everything went well, batter looked right, and marbling was pretty =)

horror started when i removed the foil that i used to tent the cake. saw that bare patch? sigh. it ripped off the "skin" which bore the great marble design. shade! (which is what the Germans would say) so, i totally wouldn't have known how the marbling would have turned out right? wrong! there was a tiny speck which wasn't affect by the foil and i could see remnents of how it would have been. So, I just had to look at that small patch and imagine it on the whole cake =X

Thank goodness the interior of the cake was ok, not the prettiest i've seen, but still passable lah.. yea? =p The cake was soft, light and not crazily oily.

I happened to come across a baking book bought long ago which had quite detailed write-ups on chiffon/sponge/butter cake methods and tips.

Before I get real naggy, lemme first post this really good recipe =) (with a few slight modifications of my own)


250 gm. Butter
80 gm. Sugar
1 tsp. Vanilla Essence
90 gm. Egg Yolk
2 Tbsp. Evaporated milk
200 gm. Cake flour
5 gm. Baking powder (about 1 tsp)
a pinch of salt
160 gm. Egg White
100 gm. Sugar

1 tbsp Cocoa Powder (sifted)
2 tbsp Evaporated Milk

*Mix thoroughly, warm up the milk if you find the cocoa powder difficult to dissolve

(1) Grease an 8” cake tin. Preheat oven to 180C. Beat butter, margarine, sugar, salt and vanilla essence until light and creamy.
(2) Add in the egg yolk one at a time and beat until creamy. Add in evaporated milk.
(3) Fold in sieved cake flour and baking powder.
(4) Whisk egg white and sugar to soft peaks and fold gently into the creamed butter mixture. You can fold in 1/3 of the egg whites first to lighten the creamed butter mixture followed by the rest of the egg whites.
(5) Spoon about half of the mixture into a separate bowl. Add in the cocoa mixture and stir well.
(6) Drop alternate spoonfuls of mixtures into an 8" round pan. Use a chopstick to pull backwards and forward through the mixture.
(7) Bake cake for 1 hour in oven at 180 deg.C or when the skewer comes clean. Turn the cake onto wire rack to cool. *I tent the cake with foil from the start of baking and remove it towards the last 10 minutes of so for the surface to brown. Oil the foil to prevent the batter from sticky to the foil.

adapted from Rei and aunty yochana

Some tips..
1. Do not over/under cream butter sugar mixture. Over creaming results in a cake with a sunken center. Under creaming results in a dense, heavy cake
2. Do not over/under bake. Over baking results in a badly cracked, dry cake or cake that shrinks upon cooling resulting in a cake with less volume. Under baking results in a heavy, wet cake.
3. personally, i find that it is ok whipping the egg whites to stiff peaks and i prefer to do so. instead of soft peaks. update: whipping the egg whites till stiff may make the cake dry. I have yet to verify this, so I guess just stick to soft peaks for the time being
4. Turn over the cake immediately after removing from the oven to prevent it from sinking and shrinking from the sides.


Ian's mummy said...

Heh! Thanks for sharing. Although a bit troublesome to have to drive over to 'deliver' a few slices of marble cake, at least you were rewarded with some creamy butter/cheese crab. :-)

The cake was ok. Just a bit dry.

But seriously, I really admire your 'never give up' spirit in baking. Keep it up. Hope this spirit plays a part in other areas of your life too!

youfei said...


hahah no problem! yea! I also agree it's also a little dry, not too sure if it was the cocoa (which i doubt so) but i think it may have been whipping the whites til stiff. Cos previously i whip till soft peaks. hmmm..

I can try again and you can still be my guinea pigs if you don't mind! hahah..though no more crabs in exchange for the time being (high cholesterol lah)..hahaha


vincent said...


We bumped into your blog and we really liked it - great recipes YUM!!! YUM!!!.
We would like to add it to the

We would be delighted if you could add your blog to Petitchef so that our users can, as us,
enjoy your recipes.

Petitchef is a french based Cooking recipes Portal. Several hundred Blogs are already members
and benefit from their exposure on

To add your site to the Petitchef family you can use or just go to and click on "Add your site"

Best regards,


Related Posts with Thumbnails